on internet filtering …

Bah! More Internet filtering issues came up again at work this week and frankly, I'm FRIGGIN' tired of Internet filters and Internet filtering and I'm tired of talking sensibly, rationally, and professionally about it.  Here's the bottom line.  It is sad but true and I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but THERE IS NO TOOTH FAIRY and INTERNET AND E-MAIL FILTERING DOESN'T WORK!!!   Get over it!!!  While I'm sure that it makes some people feel better to be doing "something," the harsh reality is that objectively, filters aren't really protecting a whole lot 'o kids.

We have this freakin' Internet filter that randomly blocks all kinds of useful sites.  It also randomly, sends kids warnings about language when they use the term "slimeball" to refer to a slimeball-ish character in the book that they're reading.  Okay … "slimeball" might be used to cyberbully some poor middle schooler someplace, but in the same forum another kid calls the character an "asshole" and … the filter does nothing.  WTF??? 

It all just gives me a headache.  In the big building, I watch what kids do online pretty closely (we have Big Brother software that the kiddos have named, "Eagle Eye.") and the wonderful reality is that 99.5% of the kids do nothing inappropriate or wrong online.  They sometimes spend too much time obsessing about a stupid game.  They sometimes sit next to each other and send e-mails back and forth like, "'sup."  They sometimes try to watch an episode of Ugly Betty on abc.com when they should be doing math homework, but all that stuff is pretty damned tame if you ask me.

We keep talking around and around and around and around about what to block and what not to block until I think my head is going to implode.  Unfortunately, a lot of adults just buy into the fear mongering and in the sincere interest of protecting kids, they're afraid to let kids onto an unfiltered Internet.  The arguments sound like this, "There are HORRIBLE, HEINOUS things on blogs out there that NOBODY should see."  You know, I have to admit that, THAT IS ABSOLUTELY TRUE and really, if somebody wanted to find pictures of really creepy nasty stuff, no filter is going to stop them from finding it.  The thing is, though, that I read something like 150 RSS feeds from blogs and sites just about everyday and while I know that I've come across some pretty raunchy pictures from time to time, it really doesn't happen all that often.  On the other hand I learn aan incredible amount by reading those sources so on balance, our filters really are doing a lot more harm than good.  The other thing is that what I always want to ask (but because I like my job … never do) is, "Jeez, what kind of creepy crap are you searching for to pull that stuff up, dude???" 

Yup … THAT IS THE QUESTION!!!

Read and post comments | Send to a friend

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “on internet filtering …

  1. I think you have a valid point here. It's true that most kids have never or perhaps never will look at anything on the internet. However, I remember my experiences as a kid, and some of the stuff that I've been exposed to (I'm 26 now, so I'd like to think that I was young enough for this to be a problem). I've seen much more that I would like to have seen. Also, I don't think that all kids are perfect and will never give in to that bit of curiosity that eventually bites us all in one form or another. I for, one, feel that using internet software is better than nothing. I would recommend http://www.contentwatch.com (I don't have kids yet, but when I do I will be using this or something similar). I suppose that what I'm saying is that saying filters don't work very well shouldn't be an excuse to use nothing at all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s